Well said mick. But do you notice it’s the same problems all over again that we have had for the last 3 seasons with no pack . Fair enough we have tried this season but the ones we have signed look unfit and not interested I wouldn’t say the chaplehows are the answer as well. And as for are tactics there are none I don’t no what sort of rugby finnigan was talking about when he took over but all I can guess what he was going on about was clueless rugby. We need a complete overhaul or a rocket up there arses to sort them out.
It is not rocket science, we have a very small squad, started training late,light on forwards and our biggest earner hasn’t laced his boots up for 18 months which strangles recruitment. next season team recruitment should already be underway we can only hope there is a plan, Wilde coming back is a step in the right direction onwards and upwards x
Its not rocket science we have a very poor coach and a team who doesn’t give there all. a major clear out and a new coach may not win every game but at least effort would be there, then again this is Widnes contracts will be thrown around like confetti to non deserving causes.
some of what you say makes sense, but a coach can only use the players he has, he did not recruit them. As for effort and commitment there are a few that step up to the mark every week - Tyler,Grady,clough to name a few.
next season will be a defining season for finnegan, it will be his team and hopefully we can move on
The core of the pack was signed by the world's most experienced coach! Rather than fading SL forwards just looking for an easy-out into work we should be looking at hard Championship youngsters looking for a chance to show what they can do. Watching Saints I really cant see Amor busting a gut for us tbh.
Honest props would make a massive difference, as Clough does when fit. Cook and Hewitt should be paying us back tbh. Tomkins will need a full medical befor taking him for another year.
Sad to say Yorkshire seems to be much better off for props and we need to look hard nearer to home. Farnworth has been promising for long enough now, he needs to take the responsibility on or he will stagnate.
Oldham and Swinton will be going down, it is unlikely Rochdale will be coming up.
Surely 2 or 3 decent forwards to be picked up there before we go down the route of any SL players, again there should be a couple to select surely.
I also think our Half-Backs are not playing well enough, is the coaching there or is it just the pack situation....I think DC has had a less than brilliant season and JL is up and down.
The sad thing is how utterly predictable this all was.
I agree & so it will remain until we can field 3 forwards on the bench & 2 props in the starting 13!
Totally agree Geoff. The first half shows we have the talent, but we just lose out physically without a front row.
Oldham and Swinton will be going down, it is unlikely Rochdale will be coming up. Surely 2 or 3 decent forwards to be picked up there before we go down the route of any SL players, again there should be a couple to select surely. I also think our Half-Backs are not playing well enough, is the coaching there or is it just the pack situation….I think DC has had a less than brilliant season and JL is up and down.
And Jack Owens has been totally anonymous.
We’re in a real mess. Other than Tyrer and Baker I can’t think of a player who’s had an acceptable season.
Oldham and Swinton will be going down, it is unlikely Rochdale will be coming up. Surely 2 or 3 decent forwards to be picked up there before we go down the route of any SL players, again there should be a couple to select surely.
Sorry CJ but you want to sign players from the two sides that will be relegated, Maybe that's the reason WHY they were relegated.
I also think our Half-Backs are not playing well enough, is the coaching there or is it just the pack situation….I think DC has had a less than brilliant season and JL is up and down.
You are correct here but I think Lyons is totally out of his ball park but half backs are only good behind a decent pack
We got Kenny Baker from North Wales who were mid-table in the 3rd Division.....
If we could afford decent SL forwards or Australians, I would of course love that, but it ain't going to happen so the only other options are getting young players from Wigan/Wire/Saints who haven't made it, tempting good Yorkshire/Cumbrian Forwards or getting the best players from the likes of Oldham and Swinton because they are the only PT teams close.
I think taking a couple of the best forwards from those clubs plus a couple of SL fringe/young players are probably the most realistic options, failing us paying a bit more to tempt people to travel further....
We got Kenny Baker from North Wales who were mid-table in the 3rd Division….. If we could afford decent SL forwards or Australians, I would of course love that, but it ain’t going to happen so the only other options are getting young players from Wigan/Wire/Saints who haven’t made it, tempting good Yorkshire/Cumbrian Forwards or getting the best players from the likes of Oldham and Swinton because they are the only PT teams close. I think taking a couple of the best forwards from those clubs plus a couple of SL fringe/young players are probably the most realistic options, failing us paying a bit more to tempt people to travel further….
Gav Roden at Crusaders looks like he could step up to this level, think hes 2nd rower, looks a unit and has plenty of pace. I know we need props but still need size all over.
Recruitment at this level isn't going to be rocket science.
SL kids seem to struggle at first at this level and need time to bed in.
Just need to copy the better sides at this level in Fev and Halifax. Admittedly they have more choice but they recruit every year by cherry picking from Batley and Dewsbury.
Yes we haven't got the numbers of clubs around us they have but there must still be options at Oldham, Rochdale and Swinton. The fact Fev picked up Frankie Halton in the off season from Swinton who is going off to SL shows there will be others who are more battle hardened to this level over this side.
One player who we could do with coming back is tangata and I’d have a look at wellington Albert again. We could also do with looking to bring in a new fitness coach as well.
I would say we have zero chance of getting Tangata back which is a shame because he is a very solid player at this level. When he left Fax to join us first time round he was being offered full time rugby and presumably good money. I doubt he’d come back to part time after the circumstances he left in. Albert is a luxury player imo, does no grafting in defence. He would be fine as an impact player in an otherwise strong side but I don’t think he’s what we need right now.
I can't believe all the excuses people are making for the lack of effort from a number of our players. Some are not good enough to be playing at championship level, some just seen to be playing their contract out before they retire.
We are struggling with lack of numbers mainly in the forwards. How long do the club expect supporters to put up with the standard of rugby we are getting at this time. It needs to be remedied sooner rather than later. Supporters need to be given some indication of the ambitions of the club or come next season numbers will really decline. Even the most ardent supporters are at the end of their tether and we need to see some improvements soon.
Just returned from York and I have read a bit of the anger, and not a lot I can't agree with, but can't ever remember anyone missing two penalty kicks to touch (Ray Dutton didn't) . Deon has had a great season but surely he will have nightmares about his inability to kick a ball 2 m into dead. We are more dangerous 75 yards out than in the 20.
Not sure why Jack's in the kicking position again ( ST groin issues?) but two missed conversions. These are things that need controlling.
We will not contest the playoffs (deservedly) and we need to look upwards and onwards. Matty at 13 (more by necessity than choice) helped us to a creditable win at Bradford and a near miss at Featherstone but wily Yorkshire coaches have negated this.Next move?
York have paid top whack for a poor season. I'm not too sure if they will be there if next season yields a similar response
Stadium is tidy. £5 return from the station on a bus is a bit pricey. Poorly stewarded, as Spelly warned us, but will be in communication with the powers that be regarding homophobic abuse of the players (reported at half time and ignored) and consistent abuse (defended only by the great and good normal YRL supporters). Its hard enough watching us atm without this. If no response RL Express amongst others beckon.
One player who we could do with coming back is tangata and I’d have a look at wellington Albert again. We could also do with looking to bring in a new fitness coach as well.
If we're going to sign forwards who've sat the whole season out with injury, I'd rather take Lewis Hatton from Swinton.