The job of replacin...
 
Notifications
Clear all

The job of replacing almost an entire pack of forwards - tough job for Coleman.

Page 1 / 3
 MT
(@mt)
Noble Member

Thought we had our best pack for a few seasons at the start of this year but with two props leaving and not being replaced and JJ not finding the form he should have been capable of we have ended the season again struggling for forwards with two backs on the bench tonight. The 2023 pack contained many players who will not be here next year -

Farnworth - rumoured to be going to Oldham

Fozard - was rumoured to be going to Sheffield/London. Hopefully staying as he has been our best performer in 2023

Amor - retired mid season having made little impact

Wilde - out of contract, hopefully staying but not seen anything either way

Lawton - supposedly Oldham bound

Bent - seemingly out of contract, recovering from a serious injury

Johnstone - under contract for next year but must be some doubt having gone out on loan

Johnson - Left without playing a game. At Oldham

FIELD - CONTRACTED

Grady - Retiring

Davies - out of contract.

Hatton - out of contract

Brown - rumoured to be yet another heading to Oldham

TILLEKE - CONTRACTED

WALKER - CONTRACTED

Three contracted forwards of whom arguably only Field is a first 17 choice when we are at full strength. Massive rebuild to do. On the plus side most of the backs are decent.

Quote
Topic starter Posted : 23/09/2023 6:34 pm
(@widnes77)
Reputable Member

Well, when you put it that way MT 😂😂

ReplyQuote
Posted : 23/09/2023 7:15 pm
(@ratboy)
Reputable Member

Matty our backs are definitely okay it is the forwards who have let us down by not punching holes down the middle. Sums ir up coming 9th and if we retained the players I am sure  with attitude the playoffs was achievable. Also not having  consistent halfbacks all season hasn't helped. 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 23/09/2023 8:35 pm
(@Anonymous)
New Member

Simply, we need at least 2 props, a decent stand off and a quality centre, Fleming has really gone off the boil

wingers - no probs

full back ?

decent 13 would be good

hibernation time coming , decided to renew 2 ST, even though only make 5 games a season

onwards and upwards 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 23/09/2023 8:44 pm
sandgroper and Ratboy reacted
(@ratboy)
Reputable Member

Posted by: @Anonymous

Simply, we need at least 2 props, a decent stand off and a quality centre, Fleming has really gone off the boil

wingers - no probs

full back ?

decent 13 would be good

hibernation time coming , decided to renew 2 ST, even though only make 5 games a season

onwards and upwards 

I would go along with that and Edge/Owens for Fullback, but gone off Jack Owens as a player. Unless find a fullback who is better quality who is versatile? Hooker I hope Fozzard and Johnstone? Then a quality centre is a must signing to break the line and to set up our decent wingers in for tries. 2 big props, 2 Back rowers and Loose forward because lost Lawton and Brown. A standoff to replace Craven, so looking at 8 new players possibly added to our squad,with the several leaving. 

 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 23/09/2023 8:55 pm
Mckviking reacted
(@sandgroper)
Famed Member

@ratboy 

The sooner we know who is leaving the better. Fozard is the key imo. With a pack that can give him quick ptb's he can open up most defences. But that should be what we are looking for anyway, whoever is hooker!

JJ might have scratched his itch now and realised that life will still go on outside SL. Iirc Sheens tried Jack Owens at hooker maybe an option if we are happy with our backs without him.

 I noticed that Rhodri Lloyd was listed at centre last week, don't know if he actually played at centre, but he was a second row.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 8:55 am
Ratboy reacted
(@sunny)
Noble Member

@sandgroper 

Wasn't Lloyd a winger/centre before he converted to 2nd row?

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 9:07 am
Northstar
(@northstar)
Estimable Member

BACKS: Fleming is no threat to any team, needs to leave. He's also got some real defensive ricks in him.

FORWARDS: seriously in need of size, power and aggression right across the pack. While I like Field, he's about as aggressive as my Nan. Ditto for Wilde.

While the forwards need a huge overhaul, a large chunk of anything freed up by Craven (and potentially Lyons) leaving, should be allocated to targeting a big, pacy (ideally overseas / south seas) centre to get people out of their seats and actually pose a threat to our opponents. We have been tame as anything this season. Easy to defend against. Teams with far less fanbase / budget seem to find the points machines in the centres, why can't we....?

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 10:23 am
 CJ91
(@cj91)
Noble Member

I notice that there are two on loan Saints players who are back rowers in the Swinton squad today: Baxter and Foster: both are being released by Saints. Maybe they will be coming here?

Dudson may divide opinion but I think he is more than decent for this level. 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 12:47 pm
(@geoffw)
Noble Member

Two more props needed? I would say 3 at the very least.Walker has done ok overall compared to whst some anticipated but he does not do big minutes. Field is a second row playing prop. Tilleke is only a squad player. Hatton no news of  as regards next year. Farnworth & Lawton are leaving.

Dudson is a no brainer a big experienced prop that we need. He did ok last time he was here in SL but an injury hampered him latterly. This new concensus that older players are useless is flawed. Lockwood & Ramsey served us well when  past 30 years of age 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 1:45 pm
(@ratboy)
Reputable Member

Posted by: @geoffw

Two more props needed? I would say 3 at the very least.Walker has done ok overall compared to whst some anticipated but he does not do big minutes. Field is a second row playing prop. Tilleke is only a squad player. Hatton no news of  as regards next year. Farnworth & Lawton are leaving.

Dudson is a no brainer a big experienced prop that we need. He did ok last time he was here in SL but an injury hampered him latterly. This new concensus that older players are useless is flawed. Lockwood & Ramsey served us well when  past 30 years of age 

I don't think anyone knows who is staying and leaving to be fair. Probably could be 4 or 5 more props. Lawton never a prop in my opinion. 

 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 2:26 pm
(@wrlfcefc1989)
Estimable Member

As stated on my post, The Dud, no thanks , it  smells of Amor and Cook. I can't see him putting a shift in, and he will hardly go for psy as you play,  and no one commented on Lyons new 2 year deal (Cravens replacement)

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 4:47 pm
PaulieWalnuts
(@pauliewalnuts)
Prominent Member

Fozard, Bent & Wilde will be here next year.

 

Paulie xx

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 5:41 pm
(@ratboy)
Reputable Member

Posted by: @pauliewalnuts

Fozard, Bent & Wilde will be here next year.

 

Paulie xx

Fozard and Wilde I would have kept for sure. Bent not too bothered, but beggars can't be choosers. Bent does tackle and work hard which is something we want from the whole squad 

 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 7:11 pm
sandgroper reacted
(@sunny)
Noble Member

LMS is leaving Saints to join the Merseyside Fire & Rescue Service, I have read. Now, he would be worth a years contract - old or not -  he is a hard working grafter.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 24/09/2023 11:51 pm
Page 1 / 3
Share: