Notifications
Clear all

Adam Lawton

Page 5 / 8
(@spike-island-90)
Honorable Member

Based off our starting 17 being fit throughout the majority of the season you would have to expect a a minimum of 4th That’s the issue but it’s not exactly just an issue for us all teams suffer with injuries throughout the season York have recruited well but our spine is still superior on paper imo Even London’s squad I’m not that convinced over, they just bullied us at our place last season rolling over our middle which I wouldn’t expect this season, but they have the ‘supposed’ benefit of FT Tolouse, Fev, London, Widnes, York, Bradford

 

I agree that top 6 is certainly plausible with our 17, beyond our 17 is a different matter.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 29/12/2020 10:46 am
(@scouseviking55)
Honorable Member

Was just off a quick look at their squad. All personal opinion isn’t it

 

Craig Hall - experienced can still do a job at FB

Chisholm - decent is either boom or bust in terms of dorm

Holmes - good at champ level

 

Forwards- Ferres, Ferguson, Harrison & Lockwood all decent at this level.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 29/12/2020 1:27 pm
(@sandgroper)
Famed Member

Got get fit, and stay fit! Have we signed a fitness guru?

ReplyQuote
Posted : 29/12/2020 4:51 pm
(@lord-lucan)
Estimable Member

Based off our starting 17 being fit throughout the majority of the season you would have to expect a a minimum of 4th That’s the issue but it’s not exactly just an issue for us all teams suffer with injuries throughout the season York have recruited well but our spine is still superior on paper imo Even London’s squad I’m not that convinced over, they just bullied us at our place last season rolling over our middle which I wouldn’t expect this season, but they have the ‘supposed’ benefit of FT Tolouse, Fev, London, Widnes, York, Bradford

not sure why fev are up there ? They have no Leeds dr this time around so it will be a watching brief on them, agree Toulouse and London, york depending on how they gel. The rest are about our standard or less

As a Fev fan I see this again and again on forums etc and this belief that Fev are totally dependent on DR still seems bizarrely prevalent.

First in terms of history - Fev have been one of the dominant teams in the Championship for over ten years now along with Leigh regardless of DR. We topped the league four years in a row before we started using DR, and we were one of the last teams to start using it. We undoubtedly had a better relationship with our DR partners (Leeds) than any other team achieved, and as a result fans of other teams used it as a stick to beat us with, but the idea that we wouldn't have been a strong team without DR doesn't stand up.

In the last couple of years the two players we used heavily on DR were Alex Sutcliffe and Callum McLelland. Sutcliffe has been replaced by Kris Welham in the 2020 squad and McLelland by a combination of Nu Brown and Tom Holmes. Holmes is very much a like-for-like replacement and was outstanding in both his previous spells for Fev whilst Brown, though he has 37 NRL appearances, is more of an unknown quantity.

It remains to be seen how we will go in 2020, but the DR-reliance thing is overdone - personally I was more disappointed that Covid meant we lost the services of Alec Susino rather than our DR players. If you want to put a question mark against us, perhaps it should be over our coach, as James Webster's win/loss career record as a head coach isn't great, but on paper the squad, which currently stands at 30 players, is probably the best or second-best (behind Toulouse) in the division.

If you want to find a weak squad amongst the supposed frontrunners, have a look at London's, especially their back division (though they are supposed to be announcing two signings today). At present, they look a mid-table team at best, though there is still time for them to strengthen.

 

 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 31/12/2020 10:56 am
(@sandgroper)
Famed Member

Seeing Webster as Agar's bag carrier is a bit of a turn off when you are a supposed to be a separate club tbh. Leaves a taste of interference and support (maybe paying most of Webbo's wages, say!) Shades of Wigan players signed up with RU clubs, paid for but never playing. More than one way of killing a cat!

I hope that nothing like that would take place but it stretches hope to think that Webster 'coaches' Leeds free, gratis and for nothing!

On the field will take care of itself but chicanery takes place unseen.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 31/12/2020 11:40 am
(@sinbad)
Noble Member
We topped the league four years in a row

Yes, I remember.Around 2008/12.It was awkward and a little embarrassing for Widnes when Rovers came here as league leaders in the final league game of 2012 after we had already been awarded a SL place, and wiped the floor with us. Incidentally, Widnes have never topped the 'second division'.Not once in all our years in it between 96/ 2020.The season we were promoted under Neil Kelly we finished second.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 31/12/2020 12:13 pm
(@sandgroper)
Famed Member

In like fashion we were dropped after finishing second to bottom, to let in Catalans!

ReplyQuote
Posted : 31/12/2020 12:29 pm
(@lord-lucan)
Estimable Member

<p style="text-align: left;">

Seeing Webster as Agar’s bag carrier is a bit of a turn off when you are a supposed to be a separate club tbh. Leaves a taste of interference and support (maybe paying most of Webbo’s wages, say!) Shades of Wigan players signed up with RU clubs, paid for but never playing. More than one way of killing a cat! I hope that nothing like that would take place but it stretches hope to think that Webster ‘coaches’ Leeds free, gratis and for nothing! On the field will take care of itself but chicanery takes place unseen.

</p>
Yes, this is exactly the sort of thing I was talking about - people making unproven accusations to do a bit of cheap pointscoring.

Webster helping out at Leeds hardly conferred any advantage on Fev, and in any case he's back at Fev now.

 

ReplyQuote
Posted : 31/12/2020 1:51 pm
(@lord-lucan)
Estimable Member
We topped the league four years in a row

Yes, I remember.Around 2008/12.It was awkward and a little embarrassing for Widnes when Rovers came here as league leaders in the final league game of 2012 after we had already been awarded a SL place, and wiped the floor with us. Incidentally, Widnes have never topped the ‘second division’.Not once in all our years in it between 96/ 2020.The season we were promoted under Neil Kelly we finished second.

Yes but that wasn't Widnes' fault. From memory I think Fev fans felt more aggrieved that the RFL refused to present the league leaders' shield after the game, hence Fev fans bringing their own replicas.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 31/12/2020 1:58 pm
(@sandgroper)
Famed Member

<p style=”text-align: left;”>

Seeing Webster as Agar’s bag carrier is a bit of a turn off when you are a supposed to be a separate club tbh. Leaves a taste of interference and support (maybe paying most of Webbo’s wages, say!) Shades of Wigan players signed up with RU clubs, paid for but never playing. More than one way of killing a cat! I hope that nothing like that would take place but it stretches hope to think that Webster ‘coaches’ Leeds free, gratis and for nothing! On the field will take care of itself but chicanery takes place unseen.

</p>
Yes, this is exactly the sort of thing I was talking about – people making unproven accusations to do a bit of cheap pointscoring.

Webster helping out at Leeds hardly conferred any advantage on Fev, and in any case he’s back at Fev now.

So you presumably know who paid his wages, or whether they were met totally by Leeds? Any saving would benefit Fev. I'm not accusing but just pointing out that from operations like that you can give out mixed messages.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 31/12/2020 2:10 pm
 CJ91
(@cj91)
Noble Member

Ok LL but you did have the benefit throughout the season of 5 SL dr players which would have helped with regard to the playoff game we had a player who was going to fev next season, played for us in the game and was nowhere to be seen, his name escapes me

Jon Grayshon.

He had a shocker that night I remember.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 31/12/2020 7:23 pm
(@lord-lucan)
Estimable Member

So you presumably know who paid his wages, or whether they were met totally by Leeds? Any saving would benefit Fev. I’m not accusing but just pointing out that from operations like that you can give out mixed messages.

I replied to this yesterday but for some reason the post never came through. I have no idea what the arrangement was, but if you think any of the Operational Rules were broken, you should contact the RFL.

In any case, we're getting away from the original point of discussion, which was whether the lack of DR will severely impact Fev in 2021.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/01/2021 11:54 am
(@lord-lucan)
Estimable Member

Ok LL but you did have the benefit throughout the season of 5 SL dr players which would have helped

Yes it would have helped, as it would for all the teams that used it. To those who say DR was a bad system, I don't disagree at all. Most Fev fans are not at all disappointed that it's gone in 2021, I just don't think it was the big difference-maker that a lot of opposing fans thought it was.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 01/01/2021 11:59 am
(@sandgroper)
Famed Member

Struck me, during an idle moment, that many of our younger lads were promising youngsters with good academy squads who for a variety of reasons (injury, change of coach etc) fell by the wayside a bit, still in the game but not following the line of progression that they had hoped for. Tim Sheens sought them out because they had something to prove, to themselves if nobody else, and gave them that opportunity.

Encouragement from our fanbase could hopefully make the difference. Here's hoping anyway!

ReplyQuote
Posted : 02/01/2021 3:10 pm
(@jdgsport)
Prominent Member Admin

Well, this is at least a good way of keeping up the number of academy products in the squad for the short-term!

Agree with a lot of the comments made on Lawton. Has the attributes and size to be a top player, but needs the desire and work rate to go with it. Hopefully he finds that. I wonder whether he might have done things differently if he had his time again.

ReplyQuote
Posted : 06/01/2021 1:48 pm
Page 5 / 8
Share: